The Greatest Expectations – Phillies Nation

The Greatest Expectations

[Dash Treyhorn, formerly of the now-defunct “” penned this post. Look for his opinion from time to time in this spot on Phillies Nation.]

Take a walk back in time with me. The year was 2006. It was December, and I was at a Christmas party. A week or two earlier, the Phillies traded for White Sox pitcher Freddy Garcia, who was a good, but not great pitcher. Durable, sure; He tossed at least 200 innings in just about every season of his nine year career to that point, with a career ERA just north of 4.00 in the American League. For us fans, it was a coup by Pat Gillick, who traded away two prospects* for an Ace.

*Gavin Floyd, the “he’s the next big thing!” pitcher, who never really stepped up in Philly but had success in Chicago, and Gio Gonzalez, who is 24-year-old left hander who had a nice year for the Athletics. Five years later, and the trade somehow gets worse.

At least, that was our perception – that Garcia was an Ace to go along with what we thought we already had – An Ace in Brett Myers (coming into his prime after a fine 2006 campaign) and Cole Hamels, who was ready to break out as a starting pitcher after his solid rookie season. And that was it. Our “Big Three,” poised to compete in the National League, backed by an offense that boasted Rollins and Utley and Victorino and Burrell and Howard, who himself was fresh off his MVP award. It was a killer offense with a stable of young and dynamic arms in a rotation that was rounded out by the capable Jamie Moyer and Adam Eaton.* It was the perfect mix for a Philadelphia team that has been starved for October action for a decade and a half after abysmal performances, near misses and disappointing September finishes.

*I remember now, having to talk myself into believing that Adam Eaton would be a good pitcher in the National League. Call it ignorance, call it a lack of understanding how the game of baseball is actually played, or call it lack of intelligent discourse about baseball, but I was firmly entrenched that Eaton was not  waste of 24 million dollars. Go ahead and laugh, you all thought it to. And that’s my point with this article: When you’ve only ever known failure, then the mediocre (or worse) things seem like really, really good ideas.

That was 2006, and we were ecstatic. Gone were the days of Omar Daal and Andy Ashby. Never again would we have to suffer through the Duckworths and Miltons. Looking back on it, it was ridiculous. Even without the benefit of hindsight, it was clear that Freddy Garcia was good, but not great, and that Brett Myers was good, but not great, and that Cole Hamels was a question mark heading into his sophomore season. Call it the folly of youth, call it a vain attempt at generating some hope for a team which there wasn’t much, or just call it “being a fan.” After all, even the most hardened fans have some modicum of hope heading into Spring Training.

Whatever you call it, it was there. The hope that the 2007 Phillies were the team to break the drought. Jimmy Rollins called them “the team to beat,” and everyone was on board. I was sold. I can’t remember being that excited for a season to begin in a while. I think we all were.

It was a silly notion. Not because we were excited about the Phillies, but because we got so caught up in it that we failed to see the forest for the trees: That this team was not as good as we thought. And the reason for that? Perspective. Simply put, we lacked it. It’s been ages since a really good baseball team played inPhilly that we forgot what one looked like.*

*For those keeping score at home, the 2007 Phillies prominently featured Wes Helms, Kyle Kendrick, Rod Barajas, J.D. Durbin, Jose Mesa, Antonio Alfonseca, Adam Eaton, Abraham Nunez and Jon Lieber, Just for kicks, also these guys: Pete LaForest, Chris Roberson, John Ennis, Francisco Rosario, Zack Segovia, Kane Davis, and Yoel Hernandez. All real players on that team.

When you look back at that team, the 2007 Phillies, the team that exceeded everyone’s expectations to win the National League East in a truly historic fashion, it makes you think. Probably something like “Wow, what a mess. Any team that signs Wes Helms and Adam Eaton and says “There, that should do it” surely cannot be that good.”

Any they really weren’t, at least not on paper. The offense was good enough to support the dismal pitching, and that crew got more good luck wins (and were the benefactors from the horrible, horrible Mets’ bullpen) than most teams that I’ve ever spent time watching. But that’s beside the point. We just didn’t know any better. We haven’t experienced that sort of embarrassment (and what an embarrassment it was, actually) of “riches” in nearly a decade, which made it easy to lose sight of the obvious. We were like a toddler pushing around cars going vroom vroom, thinking it’s the greatest thing ever, but not realizing that driving an actual car is so much better. We were spoiled by our failure.

Flash forward to the present, and my oh my, how things have changed. The 2007 Phillies did turn out to be the team that got over the hump, but it was in spite of Garcia (who appeared in 11 games before succumbing to a season ending injury), and not because of him. The Three Aces never really came to pass (despite a fine year from Hamels and a successful run as closer from Brett Myers). They pulled a doozy of a rabbit of their hat to reach October before being swept out by the eventual N.L. Champion Colorado Rockies.

In the three years since then, we’ve learned a thing or two about perspective relative to our expectations. That’s what happens when your team goes to back-to-back World Series, wins one of ‘em and morphs into the class of the National League. And this time, it isn’t just fan-rhetoric and empty hopes. It’s tangible, legit. Real.

These days, our Aces are just that – Aces. Garcia and Myers and Hamels were nice enough, but that’s it. Just nice. Their potential pales in comparison to that of Roy and Cliff and Roy and Cole, the best stable of pitchers that this town, and many others, have ever seen. By a long shot.

That’s why I like to take a look back at teams like the 2007 squad, because that perspective helps you appreciate more what you have in front of you. Then, it was a team that we believed could get the job done. Now? They may as well have been an afterthought, not fit to be spoken about in the same conversation as the teams that followed.

Like the transition between the 2007 team and the current team, so too, have the fans undergone a transformation. We are older, more experienced, more mature. We recognize the opportunity that is in front of us, and the fervor that accompanies it is genuine and real, and even better, justified.

That’s the added benefit of following a team like the Phillies at the height of its organizational apex, where the only acceptable outcome is a World Series title. I was talking to a friend of mine last week about the Cliff Lee trade, and how the wrongheaded media perception of him was summed up like so: He was afraid of the pressure of New York and of having to be “the man” in Texas. However, very few have mentioned the amount of pressure that is on Lee in Philadelphia, along with the rest of the team. Even if they win the division again, which they are expected to, and even if they advance to the NLCS, which again, they are expected to, is anyone going to talk about the 2011 team with such whimsy if they don’t win the team’s second title in four years? I don’t know the answer to that.

But it goes to show you how this team has helped the city and the fans evolve. In 2007, we accepted an overrated pitcher and touted him as our Ace. We hung the metaphorical banner of victory before the season even started and we clamored all throughout the winter about the hope that the spring would bring with it.

A few short years later, they have undergone a radical transition to a powerhouse and perennial contender with potentially the best Phillies team ever assembled. Now, anything but another parade is unacceptable.

I guess that’s a good problem to have.



  1. RichieAllen

    December 20, 2010 at 10:50 pm

    I dont know why some people on the last post think that there will be lots of complaining now that we have Cliff Lee…..I for one am happier than a pig in sh-t,and cant wait for the season to start.
    We complained last year because we WANTED this guy .

  2. Lefty

    December 20, 2010 at 11:08 pm

    I really enjoyed your piece. Perception is a funny thing, I’ve spent many winters hopeful of many Phillies teams that weren’t even close to worthy. I wouldn’t characterize it as “spoiled by failure” as much as blinded by my own love of the game and the team.

    Clearly what I see “on paper” now makes me laugh a bit about what I felt in the past. But even now I don’t believe anyone can guarantee another WFC. A bad bounce here, an injury there, they still have to play the games. But just like every other year, hope springs eternal, and I blindly believe they will win it all.

    • Pat Gallen

      December 20, 2010 at 11:25 pm

      Nothing wrong with blindly believing that. It’s certainly what many others believe as well.

  3. Phillyfanatic

    December 21, 2010 at 12:20 am

    This article was rather verbose.

  4. Greg

    December 21, 2010 at 4:56 am

    Dash, post more often, make your own account. Posts like these made/make for such an incredible read. I completely agree with your final verdict.

    I really, really, want another championship. If we get it, I’ll cry from joy.

  5. Chuck

    December 21, 2010 at 8:05 am

    Good stuff, Dash. Really good. I think you certainly have “spoken” for all of us with your piece.

  6. Brooks

    December 21, 2010 at 8:38 am

    A lot of us cried in 08 Greg as a matter of fact, I cannot help but well up when I watch the highlights of 2008.

    Nice article Dash – this season holds a lot of promise. Always the big butt in there eh? It really does not seem like we’re going way out on a ledge hoping for our key role players on offense to hit for their averages, does it?

    There does not appear to be any obstacle to prevent the Phils from going deep into the playoffs.
    07 – NLDS
    08 – WS
    09 – WS (L)
    10 – NLCS

    One other thing, another division win then a fizzle – whether it’s in the WS or NLCS – would the comparisons to the Braves of the 90’s start up?

    Heaven forbid!

  7. sigfield

    December 21, 2010 at 8:42 am

    nice post brother.

  8. Chuck

    December 21, 2010 at 8:45 am

    Brooks, yes it would I think. Although the Braves were division winners for like 14 years with only one title. So the Phillies would have a long way to go before they would match that. Still, I think the prevailing feeling is that anything less that another WFC and then the season is a bust.

  9. bfo_33

    December 21, 2010 at 9:12 am

    An interesting read, but was the roster really filled with “can’t miss” players in 2008? While Cole Hamels improved quite a bit in 2008, his record didn’t show it. Jamie Moyer, of the 82 mph fastball, lead the team in wins. 3rd on the list – Kyle Kendrick, an afterthought, basically an available arm. The best pitcher down the stretch (Myers), spent part of his summer in AAA trying to figure out how to keep the ball in the park. Our lefty specialist in the pen was waived by the Red Sox due to an inability to throw strikes. Not quite the 2010 Giants.

    Our starting center fielder had exactly one season with over 500 abs, and he played right field mostly that year. In right, we had a platoon, with the majority of the time going to a guy who never had over 500 PAs in a season.

    Our projected catcher, while a promising backstop, had 142 games started behind the plate, and was backed up by a career minor leaguer. Then there was The Beard, who managed a 0.217 BA with 238 plate attempts.

    Just like 2007, the 2008 team really didn’t look that good on paper. We had a few stars (Rollins, Howard), potential (Utley, Hamels), and a ton of question marks (pretty much everyone else). Like the 2010 Giants, the players gelled into a team, and got hot at the right time. The 2008 Phils were a surprise (although I expect them to win every year, even when Kevin Millwood was the staff ace) – as unpredictable as the 2010 Giants or the 2006 Cardinals. Here’s to 2011 being more predictable.

  10. Jay aka Phillyboy

    December 21, 2010 at 4:35 pm


  11. Chuck

    December 21, 2010 at 4:37 pm

    Amen, Jay.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Phillies Nation has been bringing Phillies fans together since 2004 with non-stop news, analysis, trade rumors, trips, t-shirts, and other fun stuff!

Browse the Archives

Browse by Category

Copyright Phillies Nation, LLC 2004-2016
Not Affiliated with Major League Baseball or the Philadelphia Phillies

To Top