Your Thoughts On Winter Meetings
Posted by Tim Malcolm, Thu, December 11, 2008 01:47 PM | Comments: 67
Posts
Opening it up to you, how do you feel about the Phillies performance in the Winter Meetings so far?
So far, the Phils have traded Jason Jaramillo for Ronny Paulino, and have extended Charlie Manuel’s contract. Everything else is rumors and heresy.
Remember, you can take into account other teams’ moves, but it’s your discretion.

















Posts: 0 jeremy
I think Ruben is waiting, but he is looking to prove himself. I see us signing Lowe, which in my opinion would be a good move to solidify that 3rd or 2nd spot depending on where you but Brett. I think the big thing this off season is to make sure we get better but at the same time have enough money to lock up and meet the arbitration numbers with guys we already have on the roster
Posted: 01:53 PM on December 11, 2008
Posts: 0 Griffin
K-Rod and Putz. Those are my thoughts. I am disgruntled.
Posted: 01:56 PM on December 11, 2008
Posts: 0 tom
I think we did the right thing not trying to get ourselves into bidding wars with the us debt team the yankees.We really dont need to go out and get players for the sake of getting players. The phillies should sign lowe and get a bullpen guy to replace seanez. I think a intresting trade we could make would be maybe pawn kendrick to the cardinals for ryan ludwig to play leftfield.
Posted: 01:59 PM on December 11, 2008
Posts: 0 Geoff
yeah at least they didnt go sign someone like burnett for insane money…even lowe isnt worth it after a certain point…in general, theres way too much disinformation coming out of the winter meetings….theyll just report whatever as fact to manipulate negotiations..
Posted: 02:04 PM on December 11, 2008
Posts: 0 Chuck P
Rumors and WAG’s aside, we haven’t done anything… our biggest offseason moves have been to essentiall let two key components of last year’s success walk. We have gaping holes right now and no clear direction. Maybe things will work out for the better in the end but right now you have to give us a solid D (and only because we haven’t done anything to completely screw things up and we have been in the mix)… the Mets have clearly gotten better and that’s going to have an impact. Not sure if we could have done anything to stop that from happening but comparatively speaking, they saw a need and they addressed it with top tier players. Our needs are SP, LF and a power hitting RH… what are we going to do to address those needs?
LOWE/DUNN or MANNY… those are top tier players. Enough of this Derosa/Ho Park nonsense.
Posted: 02:04 PM on December 11, 2008
Posts: 0 Georgie
As someone pointed out on csn, the Mets have now vastly improved their bullpen, and we didn’t run away with the division last year, did we? Give the Mets just a few more wins and we’re not even in the playoffs. Let’s hope this isn’t it for Amaro, Id be shocked if it were.
Posted: 02:04 PM on December 11, 2008
Posts: 0 Derek
and i just read on mlbtraderumors.com that the fact that the yankees signed CC made the Yanks more appealing to Lowe…and that even if the yanks get burnett they will still be interested in Lowe…..It must be nice to have an infinite amount of money to spend on players….but even if the phillies did have all that money to spend ….the owners would still make the team hover around the $100-$120million mark
Posted: 02:06 PM on December 11, 2008
Posts: 0 Jason B
Well, although the Mets made moves to correct their bullpen, their starters are still garbage once you get past Santana. I think not signing Lowe for 5 years is the biggest move the Phils could’ve made. Also, if the DeRosa trade pans out, well, it could prove to be useful come July’s trade deadline. And has anyone expressed interest in Burrell? No, which means we will likely get to resign him on the cheap for one maybe two seasons. Not a spectacular showing at the meetings but in Vegas, a gamble can cost you a lot.
Posted: 02:07 PM on December 11, 2008
Posts: 0 Elias
Phillies are already following behind and we vastly need a starting pitcher. Although the Mets bullpen has been godwhat atrocious last year, it has just amazingly improved. Damn.
Posted: 02:09 PM on December 11, 2008
Posts: 0 Geoff
its obviously not, ITS DECEMBER!! calm down…wait until the season starts or at least spring training…take it easy.. the team is very good as it is…thbey just need to fill a few holes WHICH THEY WILL DO…theyre not stupid, just because they take their time and not jump right in and overbid for players doesnt mean theyre going to do nothing at all! jeez…they won the world series using this method..amaro is using the same method except hes more aggressive than gillick and wade were…but theyre not going to roll in there and offer lowe 5 year 90 million…thats extremely stupid and would be a huge mistake…lowes good at 3 years 16mm per year TOPS, nothing more…hes solid, but old, durable, but due to break down at some point. hed be a 2 or 3, not an ace…so theres no need to pay him ace money to be a second or third guy…
Posted: 02:09 PM on December 11, 2008
Posts: 0 ped
I’m ok with keeping the championship team the way it is. Getting a quality starter would be rad.
Posted: 02:11 PM on December 11, 2008
Posts: 0 Geoff
the mets are now spending over 20mm per year, excluding wagner on their pen, and that only covers putz and k-rod! they still have a bunch of trash in there…they suckered the mariners into takiung heilman and the indians into taking joe smith..but theyve still got feliciano duaner sanchez and schowenweis and garbage like that…they have a lot more work to do…they have NO middle relief..only late relief now..settle down…
they still have jose reyes to act arrogant and ruin the chemistry in their clubhosue..so dont worry about them havbing a fresh new attitude because it wont happen…
Posted: 02:13 PM on December 11, 2008
Posts: 0 Ed
For some reason, people still think the big moves win championships. Everyone thinks the yanks and mets are the new teams to beat. Amaro is being smart so far. He isn’t doing anything crazy that might cripple the franchise in the future like trading marson, donald, or carrasco or signing a $25m left fielder with bad hair and a worse attitude. He also isn’t being taken in the lf market because he knows it is deep and the price will go down. He isn’t Wade-ing around the free agent market looking to give up draft picks either unless the ideal pitcher for CBP is reasonably available (Lowe). All in all, you can’t be upset because of his lack of moves during the showy and trendy portion of the off season. You also can’t fault him for the mets dealings (how they got putz is beyond me though).
Posted: 02:13 PM on December 11, 2008
Posts: 0 psujoe
Mets get an A+ so far, the Phillies get an incomplete, but what other NL team improved so far? We’re down a LF, a starter and our 2B won’t be starting the season. We need some help, but no time to panic.
Posted: 02:16 PM on December 11, 2008
Posts: 0 Mark
Overall, I think we’re setting ourselves up to make some solid moves. But then again, that’s all we’ve done so far is set ourselves up. Now it’s time to make some noise and show all the other clubs that we are not giving up our world title easily.
I really like our moves thus far, I just wish things could progress a bit faster than they seem to be now, but hey, that’s part of the off-season. I mean, with the economy and the amount of cash players like Burrell are looking for, they’ll have to wait it out and sign with a team for less then they desire before spring training.
Personally, I hope they sign Ibanez and Lowe.
I have a lot of trust in the Phillies front office and Ruben, though. I really believe that whatever road they take with this off-season will be for our overall best interest for years to come.
Posted: 02:18 PM on December 11, 2008
Posts: 0 Chase Mutley
The Mets greatly improved their bullpen. Ours is still better. I’ll take Lidge and his perfect season over K-Rod and his meaningless saves record and stupid glasses. If Madson is as vicious as he was in the playoffs I’ll take him as the better setup man too.
Posted: 02:26 PM on December 11, 2008
Posts: 0 NJ
It was a good deal for Seattle, Heilman’s values low but the centerpeice of that deals Franklin Gutierrez who could be pretty good. You have to respect the Mets pen now and expect the Phillies to school up to get the upper hand on them, credit to Minaya who got lucky with K-Rod but their playing catch-up with the Phillies for a reason.
Posted: 02:27 PM on December 11, 2008
Posts: 0 Matt
Who would you rather have in 2010, Myers or Lowe? I don’t see anyway we keep Myers in 2010 if we sign Lowe LT.
Posted: 02:30 PM on December 11, 2008
Posts: 0 Paul
The Phillies “big move” last year was getting Lidge. And most people laughed at that one, thinking he would implode in Philly.
Posted: 02:32 PM on December 11, 2008
Posts: 0 Grrrumpy Miner
OK Geoff…..you mention Jose Reyes’ antics,others mention how the other teams and fans hate the Mets because of their emotion and passionate fans for standing by their team….now granted,the Amazins haven’t won anything yet,and I know that.Lets see if this makes yours or any other fans mouths water.Close your eyes and picture this…Middle of a pennant race,Mets Phillies still in a heated race.CitiField,Every Met including Reyes showing no emotion,no dancing as he steals his 50th base.David Wright hits a 2 run shot,he shows no emotion,Reyes and Wright reach home,look at each other cold,stoically return to the dugout,sit down cross their legs with the other 23 players,no high 5′s or words of congratulations and the 44000 fans at CitiField as quiet as a funeral.Is that what you would want as a fan for ANY team?
Posted: 02:38 PM on December 11, 2008
Posts: 0 Joey
so far im not happy. but theres plenty of time. I think we should be trying to get younger, not trading our prospects for backups. Right now this team is in a position where sooner or later these guys will all become too expensive for them, and we dont have any one in the minors worth stepping in.
Posted: 02:43 PM on December 11, 2008
Posts: 0 edavies7
This is the worst case sceniero for the Phils. They are defending champs and they are so arrogant that they think they dont need any big name players, but guess what they do. Championships arent won with platoons and 2nd tier pitchers. Others are get better and the Phils are taking steps back. Spending money doesnt win championships but it lets you compete for them every year. Amaro do something or get out.
Posted: 02:45 PM on December 11, 2008
Posts: 0 NJ
that’s just boo bird talk, the Phils have been in on Lowe as much as they can be and which other big names should the Phils have bid on? CC, Tex, Manny?
It’s they guys on this roster that’ll dictate the success next year, you always need to try and upgrade the pitching but the Phils need more out of Rollins and Howard in particular and on his day Myers is as good as Lowe or Burnett.
Posted: 02:52 PM on December 11, 2008
Posts: 0 Malcolm
1. We picked up Paulino, Ruben is clearly up to something. A trade… but with whom and involving who?
2. I like the idea of signing Chan Ho Park as a long-reliever.
3. The Yankees are going to sign A.J. Burnett, which gives the Phillies another chance to swoop in and show some respect to Derek by giving him an offer.
Posted: 02:55 PM on December 11, 2008
Posts: 0 Jason B
ey grumpy… the Mets showed plenty of emotion last year, Didn’t you see David Wright crying like a little girl who skinned her knees on the playground as they once again coughed up their playoff hopes on the last day of the season? Let Tatise, and Reyes show all the emotion they want… their starters are still suspect as is their line-up. We are still the best team in the east.
Posted: 02:56 PM on December 11, 2008
Posts: 0 Nationals#1
grumpy miner: wah wah wah. this is a phillies blog, we can say what we want. you know what, your scenario sounds pretty nice, but would the whining bloggers shut up too?
ANYWAY… i think the phils have done ok so far. I think the winter meetings are more about being in the mix than actually doing anything, and i like that we haven’t rushed into any mistakes. the last thing we need is another big contract to eat. The only move i’m confused about is jaramillo for paulino, i guess we’ll just have to see how that pans out (i’m hoping another move is made). If paulino is an upgrade over jaramillo, do you think he’ll be flipped to san diego?
Posted: 02:56 PM on December 11, 2008
Posts: 0 Geoff
edavies…thats anembrassaing, pathetic, weak statement…you must have no confidence at all….theyre doing the same things they always do…it worked before, if theyre patient and smart in their signings and moves then theyll get back to the promised land again..
i mean really? THEY ALREADY HAVE BIG NAME PLAYERS, THEY DRAFTED AND DEVELOPED THEM ON THEIR OWN!!!! what the heck is wrong with some of you people? i was like that before, but they won, they showed that you DONT need to do what the yankees, red sox, and cubs do to win a championship…the phillies were right…does that mean they will always be right? no…but theyve earned the respect to make the moves they want to make and see how it pans out…
i really think a lot of these extreme people who SITLL think they suck have an inferiority complex of some sort….
Posted: 02:57 PM on December 11, 2008
Posts: 0 Malcolm
4. The Yankees still have a lot of money to throw around.
5. The Mets have made some excellent moves, expect them to try to make a move with Oliver Perez or Jon Garland — then the attention turns to the outfield. They will be a much improved team.
6. It’s hard to determine if the Phillies are getting left in the dust because everything is so rumor-based. We aren’t going to be able to judge this until after Ruben makes his moves.
Posted: 02:58 PM on December 11, 2008
Posts: 0 Geoff
theres a difference between showing emotion and being a total, complete, utter immature jack@$$ ….david wright is a professional, a leader, and someoone to be admired by younger players. jose reyes simply is not…plus..hes STILL no jimmy rollins….AND HE NEVER, EVER WILL BE…!
Posted: 03:01 PM on December 11, 2008
Posts: 0 mike mike
I hope howard ask for 20 million in arb and gets it stick it to these bottom line owners.
Posted: 03:03 PM on December 11, 2008
Posts: 0 edavies7
Geoff your right it worked for the Phils twice in 28 years. How many times did it work for the Yankees in the same amount of time. Dont tell me buying all-star cliber players doesnt work cause it does. It might not give you a championship every year but it puts you in aposition every year to win one.
Posted: 03:06 PM on December 11, 2008
Posts: 0 edavies7
mike mike I guess we are the only two on this site that think the Phils are way to cheap. But what do we know.
Posted: 03:07 PM on December 11, 2008
Posts: 0 RichieAllen
Geoff ,glad to hear you sticking up for the current core of players..is this the same Geoff who wanted to trade the whole team last year?
Only kidding…
Posted: 03:09 PM on December 11, 2008
Posts: 0 mike mike
Geoff one stinking time in 28 years, Do you hear me one time .two times in 138 years, mets since 1962 expansion team have three title florida marlins expansion 2 titles, diamondback expansion 2 titles, DO You hear geoff there way worked once in twenty eight years, why don’t you get it we need more to win again and meyers who was sent down to minors as your 2 isn’t good enough, blanton as your 3 has 6 of 16 quality starts happ is a 26 year old rookie dont you get it yet, and park is a disgrace do you get it yet. Do you get it yet or should I PRINT IN SPANISH OR ANOTHER LANGUAGE.
Posted: 03:09 PM on December 11, 2008
Posts: 0 NJ
edavies you can’t use that twice is 28 years line straight after winning the championship, it’s a new slate now so chill out.
Posted: 03:11 PM on December 11, 2008
Posts: 0 mike mike
YANKESS 28 TITLES. YOU SHOULDN’T EVEN MENTION THE PHILLIES IN THE SAME BREATH.
Posted: 03:11 PM on December 11, 2008
Posts: 0 Jason B
Mike Mike… that’s twce in 126 years… not 138.
Posted: 03:12 PM on December 11, 2008
Posts: 0 Don M
Madson is currently more desriable than JJ Putz… and Lidge is better than K-Rod…
so why is everyone worried about what moves the Mutts made to set themselves back again with overpriced Free Agents?
mike mike…. CHILL OUT dude… How many World Series titles can you win per season?? Cause I have a feeling that you’d be pissed even if we won three or four trophies this past season..
Posted: 03:14 PM on December 11, 2008
Posts: 0 Geoff
Because it doesnt work anymore..i guarantee you that the cubs and yankees wont even get to the WS, let alone win it…the yankees getting burnett and sabathia are TERRRIBLE, TERRIBLE, TERRIBLE signings. both of them..sabathias contract is a huge albatroiss for an voerweight, overrated player who HAS NOT PROVEN A DAMN THING!!! he SUCKS in the postseason…totally chokes when it matters most…and theyre going to give him all that money…same with burnett who hasnt been reliable in years…
they just spent over 200mm ands till counting (if you unclude burnett) on a bunch of overrated players…
the difference between the dynasty yankees and the current squads are the type of players…the yankees signed the right players, and some role players, to win their titles..now, theyll just sign anybody who gets hyped in the media…
um..the phillies behave like almost every other team not names the angels, cubs, red sox, or yankees…….or mets….even the mets are more judicious with their money than the yankees…
and, yeah, look at all those teams that won..a 100mm payroll is enough to win if you spend it properly…i mean really..i want them to sign lowe too but not at 4 years 80 mm or whatever, 70mm. thats plain stupid….jon lieber anybody?
that whatll happen to lowe once day..oen day hes just done.;..
Posted: 03:16 PM on December 11, 2008
Posts: 0 rollinsright!!
Look at Rollins numbers when he was 25 years old as Reyes is right now. Then talk…Hes definitly not rollins no doubt abou that….HE’S BETTER!!! See only fools from outta town say Reyes is immature and all that BS, they know nothing that goes on INSIDE the clubhouse. Reyes is the man, well loved in his clubhouse and well loved in NYC. Trust me if he was a “distraction” he wouldnt be a Met right now. The Mets build around Reyes and Wright, and will continue to do so for years to come. Just becase he throws a finger in the air everyone wants to get at him. But chances are if he was doing it for your team, fans will be asking front office for a Bobblehead day for him the following year….you guys have a similar guy in Shane Victarino who likes to “show people up” but instead you guys call him a sparkplug. both are no different, they both play with heart and emotion.
Posted: 03:19 PM on December 11, 2008
Posts: 0 Don M
I don’t know who “Geoff” is anymore… but I’m pretty sure that “mike mike” must be the guy posting with the name Geoff all summer
Posted: 03:19 PM on December 11, 2008
Posts: 0 Manny
I guess most deals for us will now depend on whether we sign Lowe.
Posted: 03:19 PM on December 11, 2008
Posts: 0 mike mike
eadvies I promise to never say they are cheap if someone can tell me how they sold themself as small market. They got the league to pay them for four straight years revenue for small markets teams. how when they are the fourth largest market.Prior to cbp being built they were 23 in payroll at 27 million they went up to 33 million with the league giving them 11-13 million that year and for the next three years there payroll went up as they got money. how did they sell it to the league. they are cheap bast##. no one wants to hear it they are blind to the fact they refuse to spend money on latin market, that they drafted players who didn;t project as high in the draft when they had extra picks and refuse to go over slot on good prospect instead let them walk joe saunders kyle gibson jd drew, brandon workman. to name a few so how can people defend them it is jus blind loyalty because they are the phillies. I love the team hate giles and montgomery, betz they are cheap Bast###.Prove me wrong.
Posted: 03:20 PM on December 11, 2008
Posts: 0 Jason B
Geoff: Couldn’t have said it better myself. Sabathia doesn’t even want to play in NY and was probably pressured by the union to not turn down that offer. We know what happens to players who don’t want ot be in NY. Sabathia’s post season era is over 4 and he showed that he can be rattled. Wait til he sees the NY media everyday… talk about rattled. You’re right, the Cubs and the Yankees won’t even be in the world series so this is a moot point.
Posted: 03:22 PM on December 11, 2008
Posts: 0 Kevin
Didn’t the Phils buy their 93 team and still lose a championship?
I think Amaro is being patient for the right reasons.
Have some faith.
Is Burrell out of the picture for good? Am I the only one that would like to see him back next year?
Posted: 03:23 PM on December 11, 2008
Posts: 0 mike mike
Don M isn’t posting under a different name something you business types do to protect your name. I don’t have to snoop that low. I am a man and speak my mind if you agree or not
Posted: 03:24 PM on December 11, 2008
Posts: 0 Geoff
dude, you guys are sad, pathetic human beings…you already think they suck and theyre going to lose…because the mets overpaid for two guys and the yankees set MLB back 10 MORE years by wasting all that money,…sabathia is going to be the next barry zito..i will basically guarantee that..total fraud overrated hype monster…
all those other teams that won…they all spend money similarly to the phillies….um, and the yankees havent done a damned thing since those dynasty teams…you knwo why? because baseball doesnt work that way anymore…you need to develop your own talent and keep it…
teams that develop it and quickly trade it away (KC, pittsburgh) they cant grow together long enough to win…teams that buy it all have players with very little in common and no incentive to work hard because theyre making 20mm a year…that doesnt work either…
ever since the angels won the WS they exponentially increased their spending and since theyve done that they havent been back…the marlins wait until they have the right core of players then they fill in teh final pieces and make a run then sell it off…ok selling it off isnt cool but they wait, and they spend wisely…
the point is…wreckless idiots liek the steinbrenners are the reason why america is about to become a third world country….just spend spend spend and rack up more and more debt…idiot…
should the phillies spend more? probably could jack it up to 130mm or so..but theres no need to go insane…their payroll will shoot up to 110+ because of their arb cases anyways,…
Posted: 03:25 PM on December 11, 2008
Posts: 0 Maverick
I don’t think the Phils are cheap relative to other teams. However when your nextdoor neighbors are the yanks and mets and the redsox only a few doors down its easy for to think they are cheap.
Also, spending big money doesn’t mean your getting a sure thing…
I do think you have to be smart before shelling out major cash.
The long line of Free Agent Bust’s is extensive.
Tori Hunter, Andru Jones, Eric Gagne, Barry Zito..
And remember when Mike Hampton signed that mega deal 8yrs 115 mil? that turned out well
Posted: 03:26 PM on December 11, 2008
Posts: 0 Don M
it was just a joke because all summer long me and Geoff went back on forth the way you are doing with everyone else right now..
you are a bitter person and should seriously stop complaining about the number of total World Series such and such teams have… OUR TEAM just won it this year.. be happy
Posted: 03:28 PM on December 11, 2008
Posts: 0 Don M
Sabathia is leaving NY in 3 years for the West Coast… instead of $100 M over 5 years somewhere.. the Yankees are giving him $90 for 3 years.. and then he’ll opt out and go play wherever he wants.. somewhere on the west coast
Posted: 03:31 PM on December 11, 2008