Quantcast


Guess the Top 10 Greatest Phillies

Posted by Brian Michael, Mon, March 02, 2009 01:28 PM | Comments: 27
100 Greatest Phillies, Posts

We’re getting close to the end of our 100 Greatest Phillies countdown.  The Final 10 will begin to be revealed on St. Patrick’s Day and you have a chance to guess the top 10.  If you submit an entry that has all 10 in the correct order you will win an awesome Phillies prize. Make sure you check who’s on the list already.

Responses are due at 11:59 p.m. Friday.

Avatar of Brian Michael

About Brian Michael

Brian Michael has written 1142 articles on Phillies Nation.

Brian is the CEO of Phillies Nation which he founded in July of 2004.

 
 
  • Posts: 0 Phil

    im confident i got the top 10 but not the right order. can we enter more than once, tim?

     
  • Posts: 1650 Tim Malcolm

    Avatar of Tim Malcolm

    Sorry, you can’t enter more than once.

     
  • Posts: 0 Phil

    Can you check my list and at least tell me if I’m close: :P

     
  • Posts: 0 fortyb

    a couple of questions Tim…

    who was the mysterious number 40 on the list? It wasn’t in the archive.
    where were the two members of the 2008 team in 26-50?

    My guesses were that Burrell and maybe Lidge got moved down a bit. Can a guy have a perfect season in his only season with the franchise be in the top 25? Why not?

    My guesses for the 2008 team in the top 25 – Rollins, Howard, Utley, Hamels, Lidge, and Burrell. Anyone think I missed anybody?

     
  • Posts: 0 Phil

    Fortyb: Hamels was picked. I don’t think Lidge made the list at all. Howard and Utley will be top 20. Burrell is coming up soon, he might be top 20 but I’m thinking he’s going to be like 22. Rollins is top 10 for sure.

     
  • Posts: 581 Brian Michael

    Avatar of Brian Michael

    fortyb – good eye, thanks. It was King Cole, but not tagged. It’s in the archives now.

    Note a deadline of Friday has been added…otherwise it’d be too easy.

     
  • Posts: 0 Phil

    I should have waited to make my list, but regardless I still think I got the top 10 for sure. Maybe not in the right order, but I got top 10.

    Question to the Phillies Nation guys: If no one gets them in order will you give a prize to the person that is closest?

     
  • Posts: 1650 Tim Malcolm

    Avatar of Tim Malcolm

    Keep in mind I discarded men who played one year for the Phillies. So Lidge is not on the list.

     
  • Posts: 0 Phil

    Darn Tim, so does that mean So Taguchi and Geoff Jenkins aren’t in the top 10? I had them on my list.

     
  • Posts: 0 Fuhs

    You might as well have had us guess 2-10. I mean we ALL know the Phanatic wins, right?

    His career hits 31 years next month, AND he’s already in the (mascot) Hall of Fame! Great baserunning, makes sure every bald head is well shined. The only minus is his road/home split.

     
  • Posts: 0 Jim

    you guys are crazy if you think any current player is on the top 10. rollins utley howard and burrel should all be top 25 material but none of them will sneak into the top 10.

     
  • Posts: 581 Brian Michael

    Avatar of Brian Michael

    Yes, if no one gets it exactly right, the closest person will get a prize…though it won’t be as cool.

     
  • Posts: 0 Chuck P

    I feel like I might have the right 10 but I don’t know if the order will match up. There’s one name in particular that I believe some will rate higher based on name recognition.

     
  • Posts: 0 Phil

    Chuck P…I know exactly who you are talking about, but I don’t wanna give it away. I wanted to put him as #8 or so, but I put him as #3 because of his name.

     
  • Posts: 0 Phan in TN

    When I win, I want a life sized Phillie Phanatic replica (w/fur) shipped to my house in TN.

    I’m quite certain that I have at least 9 in the correct order.

     
  • Posts: 0 Jeltzismyhombre

    I’m curious what criteria Tim is using for selection. It seems quite subjective. I tend to go with James since he’s hard to disagree with. But there are other highly statistical methods for choosing a starting point.

    In case anyone is wondering, the Phillies who placed in Bill James’ Top 100 Players of all-time (based on the 2000 edition of his Historical Baseball Abstract) are as follows:

    20. Grover Cleveland Alexander*
    21. Mike Schmidt
    33. Pete Rose*
    40. Nap Lajoie*
    78. Steve Carlton
    96. Robin Roberts
    99. Ed Delahanty

    * Played significant portions of their career as a non-Phillie.

    I remember a really interesting article in the Inquirer when the Abreu trade happened showing that in terms of Win shares / 162 games Abreu was actually the 2nd most valuable player in team history, ahead of Schmidt but behind Alexander. That would vault him above more esteemed position mates Gavy Cravath, Johnny Callison, Sam Thompson and Chuck Klein, who themselves should all place in the Top 25. A very good argument could put him in the Top Ten. We’re deep in RF historically, but with no one great player. Maybe Pete Rose.

     
  • [...] Win a prize for guessing correctly the top 10 in our 100 Greatest Phillies. Click here to fill out your form. Enter before 11:59 p.m. [...]

     
  • Posts: 0 Jamie

    Hey, what about a prize for the most outrageous top 10 Phillies of all-time? What a beaut a list sprinkled with the likes of Andy Ashby, Adam Eaton, Carlton Loewer, etc… would be

     
  • Posts: 0 Jeltzismyhombre

    Were all three you names Lee Thomas first round draft picks, or did Ed Wade pick one or two of them?

     
  • Posts: 0 Jamie

    Nope, I think they were all Lee Thomas

     
  • Posts: 0 Chuck P

    I went the other way, Phil. I put him lower on my list than others might have him… I put him 8.

     
  • Posts: 0 ryan

    #1? : obviously it’s going to be Rico Brogna.

     
  • Posts: 0 Phan in TN

    I protest. ryan was looking at my answers before I submitted that thingy.

    I would like to change numbers 6 and 8 to Kevin Stocker.

     
  • [...] Win a prize for guessing correctly the top 10 in our 100 Greatest Phillies. Click here to fill out your form. Enter before 11:59 p.m. [...]

     
  • [...] Win a prize for guessing correctly the top 10 in our 100 Greatest Phillies. Click here to fill out your form. Enter before 11:59 p.m. [...]

     
  • [...] Win a prize for guessing correctly the top 10 in our 100 Greatest Phillies. Click here to fill out your form. Enter before 11:59 p.m. [...]

     
  • Posts: 0 Fran

    wow that was tough. I think I have a pretty legit list though

     
 
Leave a Comment

>> Create a new Phillies Nation account.
>> Already registered with Phillies Nation? Log in here.
>> Comment without logging in:






Please ensure your comments comply with our Comment Policy.