Commentary: Two Scenes Say A Whole Lot
Posted by Tim Malcolm, Wed, July 15, 2009 09:16 PM | Comments: 98
Commentary, Posts
When you duck away from the charity of writing analysis you believe is insightful, you gain a new appreciation for the water in which you once bathed. With my head in the tub for long enough, I’ve began to notice something odd: The Philadelphia Phillies are on a whole new level.
These aren’t your father’s Phils. Heck, they’re not even your great-grandfather’s Phils. I don’t think Chuck Klein ever envisioned this type of popularity.
In a short glance of time, the Phillies swept through the Mets and cleaned up the dregs of the National League Central division, coasting into the All Star break with fat tummies. And Charlie Manuel only expanded those belts, giving Jayson Werth a pat on the back with an all star label and placing fan-rewarded Shane Victorino into his starting lineup. Watching last night’s All Star Game, I found myself applauding so much that I couldn’t feel my hands anymore.
It felt odd rooting for so many individuals on an all star team. It felt like the great swindle of 1993, the greater swindle of 1994 and the greatest swindle of 1995, when even Heathcliff Slocumb and Tyler Green hitched a ride on the all star wagon. This time, however, the spots were deserved. (You could make cases for Victorino, Werth and Ryan Howard, since you should factor in some of the 2008 ledger — or else we should have two all star games again, shouldn’t we?) These boys suddenly became the face of the National League, seen in the boyish crew melon of Howard, the pranking eccentricity of Victorino, the steady nerves of Werth, the wise adulation of Raul Ibanez and the stoic manliness of Chase Utley. Oh, and let’s not forget Manuel, the wrinkle-faced, white-haired teddy bear with a mouth the size of Lake Dinty Moore.
Take Stan Musial kissing fingers in a convertible, or Carl Crawford robbing a home run, or any one of the 7,100 camera cuts of Albert Pujols. To me, the lasting picture of the All Star Game festivities was Manuel, clad in a clean, black two-piece suit and tie at the media day conference, handing reporters the same business he’d hand reporters before a Phillies playoff game. To Manuel, this wasn’t simply a break from real baseball, nor was it a chance to let loose in a casual black button-down. This whole all star business was Charlie Manuel’s big moment — his opportunity to tell the world, “Look. I got here by winnin’! I earned this here!”
Far beyond 2008, the Phillies have extinguished the ghosts and turned to the business of winning in 2009. But being an all star manager isn’t simply a perk, it’s a testament to your efforts at work. It means you were good, real good. Manuel sure earned that managerial spot, just as the Phillies earned all the attention they gained during all star weekend. Your world champions — and not just that, but your still first place Phillies. Not only did they win last year, but they’re looking purty good this year.
Pedro Mania
The dust mites that flew far enough from Saint Louis found a veritable amusement park Wednesday at Citizens Bank Park. There, newly signed Phillies pitcher Pedro Martinez greeted the media with honesty and guffaws. Reporters bounced every question imaginable at the three-time Cy Young winner, and he swatted his answers back to them without an ounce of transparency. Martinez is the real deal, and no matter how much you could loathe him in blue and orange, you love him now. You have to — he gave us everything we wanted.
More than that, though, Martinez gave the Phillies that amusement park. It’s the type of scene reserved for the pantheon players (in baseball immortality and immorality): Clemens, Bonds, McGwire. Those guys. Sure, Martinez may not have that one thing in common, but he’s definitely in that competitive level. He’s beyond the game. And like a big-market, big-name, big-city, big-bullswat team, the Phillies grinned wide as they lapped up the pantheon pitcher. Even if he doesn’t throw a pitch at Citizens Bank Park, he hammered my point home.
Two very different men sat at skirted tables and spoke to reporters within 48 hours. One a huckling West Virginian, a former ball-blaster in Japan. The other a smooth-talking Dominican, a Hall of Fame pitcher if he ended it now. They couldn’t be farther apart in what they were given, and in what they took. And yet both men spoke with dead seriousness about their intentions: To win baseball games. Manuel for his National League all stars. Martinez for his Philadelphia Phillies.
And both men each wore a clean, black two-piece suit and tie.
These scenes both represented bookends to a break filled with appreciation for the past. The great team of the National League had their time, parading out their stars, lauding Stan the Man and giving their new Hall of Fame player a chance to catch the president’s pitch. It seemed oddly fitting, then, that the new great team of the National League was stealing the headlines on either side of the show.
I can’t help but feel amazed that the Phillies are suddenly bubbling with popularity. This is the same team that stirred in the bowels of the National League for not just years, but decades. Heck, over a century. And while we can’t tell if this will all last too long, living in that moment feels all the more special.
So if you’ll excuse me, time to go back underwater.
Tim Malcolm is the former everyday writer of Phillies Nation. He’ll post again when his head comes above water. Until then, e-mail him at tim@philliesnation.com.
















Posts: 0 Manny
Good to see you again, Tim!
What a great, refreshing piece… It’s great to read this and appreciate the bigger picture… something’s big going on with the Phillies and you couldn’t have said it any better.
Posted: 09:34 PM on July 15, 2009
Posts: 0 Chutley
Timmmmayyyy great great article.
Posted: 09:43 PM on July 15, 2009
Posts: 0 NateB
we want more Tim on here! good article. it’s a great time to be a Phillies phan!
Posted: 09:44 PM on July 15, 2009
Posts: 0 Bobby in Boston
When Pedro is in the mood, he gives it up for the media as good as anybody. Funny, self-effacing, honest. After watching Pedro for about ten years up here, it will be interesting to see how the Boston media follows his exploits in Philly. I’ll keep you posted. Pretty trippy to see him in Phillies red.
One thing’s for sure. This might be the first time anyone’s strained a shoulder signing a contract.
Posted: 09:50 PM on July 15, 2009
Posts: 0 The Dipsy
Great freakin column, Timbo. I’ll be it feels good to step away from the droning, white noise that is the PhilliesNation and come back all freshened up!
The Dipsy
Oh, and by the way, who’s this Roy Halladay fella???????
Posted: 09:52 PM on July 15, 2009
Posts: 0 Philsphan
Tim, please stay! You made this site and it’s not even close to the same without you. No one puts into words the passion and energy every one of us fans feels about the Phillies like you do.
Posted: 09:54 PM on July 15, 2009
Posts: 130 Amanda Orr
Great article Tim!
Posted: 10:07 PM on July 15, 2009
Posts: 0 Phillygirl
Awesome article Tim. What you just said was exactly how many Philly Phans feel, but can’t put into words. Your ending, about how long they will win for, is why I am nervous about Halladay. Giving up years of winning for one that we are set to win now. (Yes we need starting pitching, I know that as well as anyone, but we’ve been doing pretty decently so far.)
Posted: 10:14 PM on July 15, 2009
Posts: 0 Griffin
Tim. Is the. Man.
Posted: 10:22 PM on July 15, 2009
Posts: 1376 Pat Gallen
Tim, excellent. I liken it to Red Sox Nation. They stunk for a long, long time, and finally, a group of guys turned them into the Nation they are now. We here in Philly finally have that. A group of guys that can possible make this into s dynastic team and city. It’s definitely an exciting time to be a Phillies fan, and for the time I’ve been on this earth, I cant remember it being this insane. Everyone’s aboard.
Posted: 10:24 PM on July 15, 2009
Posts: 0 VuctorinoPhan 8
Great article Tim! I’m new to toe site and Twitter but I’m really enjoying getting familiar with you guys.
Posted: 10:34 PM on July 15, 2009
Posts: 0 karen
Great piece! That is so true but you put it in words so accurately that it made me understand a bit of the humble-ness and respect that most of those on the phils have
Posted: 10:41 PM on July 15, 2009
Posts: 0 Miles
Yeah what a bizarre couple of days to be a Phils fan. It was weird to see us in the news so much. Great to see a post from you Tim.
I’ve stressed this whole concept multiple times on this site to people who are frustrated by the Phillies when they go into their brutal slumps. At least we are frustrated with playing poorly because we don’t want to lose our NL East lead. That’s a heck of a lot different than being frustrated because we have no hope for the team. The core of this team will surely go down as one of the finest, if not the finest, in Phils history.
Btw, Andrew Carpenter looked straight NASTY in the AAA All-Star game (which is still going on on ESPN2 if you want to tune in). Three batters, 3 Ks. I believe he had 5 swings and misses out of 10 total pitches. Not bad, folks.
Posted: 10:43 PM on July 15, 2009
Posts: 0 rob5000
So… No sooner did I comment on my distaste for recent articles on this site do I come across this gem of a piece. Tim, I don’t know you and I don’t know how you do it, but for some reason you always strike a new chord. Will you just come back full time?? I’ll throw down some bills, hell I’ll start a fund if that’s what it takes.
In all seriousness though, great article. Glad to see you still have a little time for philliesnation. You always seem to personify exactly how I’m feeling. Sure, it was Pujols’ show and St. Louis is the hub of baseball, but the Phils stole the show, a testament to the fans. Surreal.
Posted: 11:33 PM on July 15, 2009
Posts: 0 David
While the article was generally well written, I do think you go a little overboard with your biases. How are the Phillies the new great team of the national league? Because they won a single world championship in the last 28 years, or is it because they have won a total of two ever. Or is it because they have the most losses in baseball history? Give me a break. And I hate to tell you, but the Phillies are not popular outside of Philadelphia. I have lived all over the east coast, and I have only ever met one person outside of PA who gave a crap about them, and he was from Philly originally. And no, you shouldnt take someones 2008 second half into consideration when chosing an allstar player, otherwise Manny should have been chosen. Its not the 2008-09 all star game, just 2009. You could make the best argument that Werth should have gone, but Vic and Howard should not. Unfortunately Charlie is a homer, and Vic needed to go door to freakin door to make the team. And then he started. The whole thing is a joke. The fact that seemingly ALL phillies fans are incapable of being even a little bit objective about their team is damaging to your credibility when it comes to baseball intelligence as a whole. You’ve got alot of spirit Philly fans, but you need to wake up to reality sometimes.
Posted: 12:15 AM on July 16, 2009
Posts: 0 David
@rob5000, How did the Phils steal the show? By having the most people there, courtesy of Charlie? Phils players were a combined 1-7 with a run scored. Utley made a very good defensive play, but that was about it. The only thing the phils stole were the roster spots of more deserving players [Im not including Utley and Ibanez, they deserved to be there]
Posted: 12:21 AM on July 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Miles
First of all David, the whole “nationwide popularity” thing doesn’t happen all at once. Boston’s popularity has grown leaps and bounds since they took down the Yanks and won the Series in ’04. If this same Phils nucleus continues with their success, they will no doubt lead fans across the county to become fans. All great teams do that.
As for us not being objective, you obviously don’t read our posts from day to day. Trust me we love our team, but we certainly do not put our guys on a pedestal. In fact, many of us have called for Werth to be benched in the first half, yet he ended up being an All-Star.
As for Vic not deserving it, I just don’t see the argument. Unless you believe that you have to slug your way to an all-star game, he certainly deserved the nod, more so than Werth in my estimation. When you look at outfielders, specifically centerfielders, he was very worthy after Beltran had to bow out. A gold glove outfielder hitting around .310 doesn’t deserve to be on the team?
Posted: 12:27 AM on July 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Miles
Also, David, you act as if no All-Star manager has ever selected his own players. It happens every year so get over it. And the Phils 1-7 appearance was no better or worse than the rest of the NL’s poor attempt to do anything. They had 18 straight batters retired. You make it seem like everyone else hit the cover off the ball.
Posted: 12:32 AM on July 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Mazinman
Nice to see you back posting already Tim. As always I enjoy your writing. Its nice to see a lot more Phils caps and shirts in my neck of the woods. It was getting lonely for a while there!
Posted: 12:58 AM on July 16, 2009
Posts: 0 kathie Brenneman
oy, tim malcolm is a crummy writer.
Posted: 03:07 AM on July 16, 2009
Posts: 0 kyle
In all honesty, 3 lines in I knew it was Tim.
This site needs him back.
Posted: 03:49 AM on July 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Brooks
Tim, your passion comes apparent when you write and it is a gift.
Regarding Pedro – I cannot agree at all. To me he personifies what a mutt is through and through – talented and full of himself. Does NOT fit into the team environment that the Phils have worked hard to put together – even in one of his first meetings with reporters after the deal became official – what did he talk about? HIS legacy (among other things).
I just think he is a cancer and regardless of how well he pitches (if/when he returns off the DL), he will be let go after this season – take that to the bank guys.
Posted: 05:10 AM on July 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Miles
Brooks, even the idea of keeping him around next year makes me nautious. I hope that is how Ruben feels as well. If Pedro happens to pitch well down the stretch, go let him sign a nice 10 million dollar deal somewhere else. Not here.
Posted: 07:13 AM on July 16, 2009
Posts: 0 mick
I do not know about you Tim, but the Phils have the talent to be competitive for a number of years–to give up blue chip prospects at this point for anybody gives me an uneasy feeling. The recent Yankee and Red Sox runs have been done with a key group of home grown players—Phils are in this boat presently—they need to be careful not to rock this boat
Posted: 07:43 AM on July 16, 2009
Posts: 0 poconoPete
Tim the phillies a great team…thats like saying Obama is a great president ….come on the NL East sucks this year…and sucked last year…they’ll need more then luck to ever become great….but at least now they have a translator for Charlie….Pedro…we’ll all know what Charlie is saying….finally.
Posted: 08:48 AM on July 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Miles
PoconoPete….excuse us for playing in the best division in the NL for the greater part of the decade. The NL East has a bad three months and all of a sudden it is a joke to everyone….
How about when the Cards won the series after winning 82 stinking games, which was 4 less than the Phils won that year if I’m not mistaken. Saying that WS winning teams are not great is the very definition of sour grapes, even if you don’t agree with how they got there.
And how are the other National League divisions any better? The central is full of mediocre teams. Milwaukee, St. Louis, and Chicago are decent but I think most baseball experts would take the Phils head to head against any of them. The west has a dominant force in LA and a good young team in San Fran. The Rockies are ok, but are about as streaky as the Phils. The DBacks and Padres are brutal.
Posted: 09:01 AM on July 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Phan in TN
enjoyable read
Posted: 09:06 AM on July 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Jessep
Great article. Two great articles in two days. I’m mostly responding to David & Miles and the article here….With all due respect to Phillies fans, management and the team… to say they are like the Red Sox of the NL is a little overboard no? More people are paying to see the Cubs, Dodgers, Padres, Mets, Nats, and Braves on the road than they are the Phillies. Now I’m not saying those #s prove 100% that for instance the Nats are more liked (obviously it’s probably a cheaper ticket) but you gotta consider the Cubs, Dodgers and Mets and maybe even the Braves as having a large following on the road right now just based on the numbers. I mean… the white Sox won it a few years ago and they were celebrated at the AS Game also… you don’t see them as being the new great team of the AL do you?
I totally agree that there is no way you should take a 2nd half into consideration for the All-Star Game. I didn’t see Melvin Mora get recognition for his 2nd half, did you? What about Adam LaRoche?
If you honestly believe Howard deserved it over Sandoval you’re being too much of a homer. BUT I do believe Manuel earned the opportunity to pick Howard…. I just think Sandoval should have been on that team more than both Vic and Howard.
I mean in the OF alone… Braun, Dunn, and Kemp are having better years than Victorino.
Boston’s popularity grew when the new owners took over… not just in 2004. It wasn’t one series that did it… it was a snowball effect of fan relations, and improving the experience at Fenway and showing a willingness to go get the players they need. The 04 LCS was just the moment it all came together.
And as for Pedro I’ve said it once and I’ll say it again. He is exactly what Phils fans hated about the Mets. Hell he CREATED the atmosphere that you all hated so much… and now he’ll be wearing your uniform. Funny how things work out sometimes huh?
Posted: 09:14 AM on July 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Maverick
Tim, your writing sucks…. but not as bad as these other clowns you got on here… welcome back.
btw.. anyone see that the Phillies have the most ESPN “Webgems” in all of baseball this year! I think this speaks to what tim was saying
Posted: 09:16 AM on July 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Morris Buttermaker
Pedro might bring the Phillies the swagger they need. I was thinking back when TO first joined the Eagles and how much fun that season was. The Eagles and their fans went into every single game thinking they would win. The Phillies are the World Series Champions and have 5 All-Stars, they need to start acting like it. No more getting swept at home by teams like the Orioles. And maybe the Phillies can start putting teams away early in the game, which they have done the past week. But there were a few game against the Red and the Pirates where they let them get out early, and had to come back. Those teams stink, the Phillies should put up runs early and often against them.
And the NL East is pretty bad. The Marlins are a strong team who can hit, but have horrible fielding and mediocre pitching. The Mets and Braves can’t get anything going for more than a series. And the Nats are the worst team in baseball. The Phillies should have this division wrapped up by now.
Posted: 09:17 AM on July 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Jessep
Cards won 83 the year they won it all.
Posted: 09:19 AM on July 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Jessep
Josh Johnson is better than any starter on Philly right now… yet Florida has mediocre pitching eh?
Posted: 09:23 AM on July 16, 2009
Posts: 0 LH
Tim, you remind me of my brother who was blessed with a book and a pen in each hand out of the womb. Enjoyed your rebirth article.
Posted: 09:36 AM on July 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Don M
Josh Johsnon is one pitcher… a very good one..
but the rest of there staff is nothing special.. I think the Braves have better pitching than the Marlins do
Nolasco had to be sent down earlier.. maybe he’ll respond like Brett Myers last year, who knows? Andrew Miller and Chris Volstad might be really good one day.. but haven’t really shown that yet . Volstad can look nearly unhittable one game, and then have to be removed in the 3rd inning his next time out.
He’s only 22 or 23 years old though, so he’ll be good.. but they’ll probably trade him by then
Anibal Sanchez has been on the DL, after getting rocked to start the year..
Marlins could be dangerous.. but I wouldn’t bet my money on them making the playoffs this year
Posted: 10:14 AM on July 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Don M
Braves are the team to watch
Tommy Hanson = 2.85 ERA
Jair Jurrgens = 2.91 ERA
Javier Vazquez = 2.95 ERA
Derek Lowe = 4.39 ERA
K Kawakami = 4.45 ERA
IF they can get any kind of steady offense (maybe Church replacing Franceour will help that?) they will really be a team to watch down the stretch
Posted: 10:17 AM on July 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Chuck
To take Morris’ point a bit further…..if Pedro never pitched a game but helped bring some “swagger” the Phillies need…..then the $1 million was very well spent. He would be sort of a glorified over-paid cheerleader. For the stretch run that could be very valuable.
Jair Jurrjens is probably better than anyone on the Marlins staff besides Johnson.
Posted: 10:28 AM on July 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Geoff
The Braves are going to trade one of theier starters for a power bat I think. Dont forget, Tim Hudson is returning soon.
Josh Johnson is diesel. Nolasco is good but has struggled this year. Chris Voltron is ok. Miller is ok. Their bullpen sucks.
The Mets are all injured and I dont think theyll be back healthy long enough to really put something together.
Posted: 10:31 AM on July 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Don M
yea but Tim Hudson coming off Tommy John.. you have no idea what he can give you this year..
They need to trade for a bat..
Chipper Jones leads them in HRs with 9
Yunel Escobar leads them in RBI with 44
They need some offense to contend
Posted: 10:39 AM on July 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Manny
Don, Ricky Nolasco is already responding ala Brett Myers 2008… With the exception of his last outing, in which he gave up 7 runs despite striking out 8, Nolasco has a 1.54 ERA since coming back from AAA.
I see your point about the Braves’ solid rotation –especially after adding Hanson–, but I’m still more scared of the Marlins. Hanley Ramirez (who started the season slowly) is finally getting into a groove and I expect him to carry this team, just like Pujols has been doing it with the Cardinals. The Braves don’t have a dangerous lineup at all, and I doubt that adding Church and McLouth will do the trick.
I could definitely see the Marlins getting on a hot streak (with good pitching and hitting), but not the Braves (very good pitching but poor hitting).. Marlins seem more balanced.
Posted: 10:39 AM on July 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Jessep
The biggest acquisitions at the trade deadline in the NL East could very well be.
Mets: Reyes, Beltran healthy.
Braves: Hudson.
Posted: 10:45 AM on July 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Geoff
This is the weekend that big trades start to trickle in. This weekend last year Sabathia was traded. Harden was traded a year ago next week. Then the Phillies nabbed Blanton a few days after that.
The first big trade I think will be Freddy Sanchez and possible Zach Duke going to the Gigantes for a deal built around Jonathan Sanchez, a good pitching prospect (oen of their big three stud starting pitchign prospects, but BUT baumgartner) and a good infield prospect.
I heard the BRavos have been trying to trade Yunel Escobar because the manager doesnt like him…
Posted: 10:55 AM on July 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Amazinsux
I see jessup is back on the pipe again today. Try the Muts blog. That’s where all the losers are. You will fit right in there.
Posted: 11:00 AM on July 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Jessep
You set such a high standard of excellence among phillies fans amazin
Posted: 11:05 AM on July 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Miles
Yeah Geoff I heard Cox has pulled Escobar llike 4 or 5 different times this year for different idiotic things he has done on the field like not hustling or not trying in general.
To continue the above discussion about the Phils growing popularity or lack thereof, it’s ridiculous to even suggest the Padres and Nats travel better than the Phils. There has been a noticeable Phan presence at every away series we’ve gone to this year. I would argue that we almost match Nats fans at their home games. Teams like the Mets and Yanks are always going to travel better because of the NY market, and Boston and the Cubs have longer, more storied franchises.
And as I mentioned earlier, a whole generation of kids is growing up and seeing a team full of marketable players that they will attach themselves to. I think in 15 years there will be a much more legitimate “Phillies Nation” that was born with the nucleus of Utley, Howard, Rollins, Hamels, and Victorino.
Posted: 11:11 AM on July 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Jessep
And what did I say that was so “back on the pipe,” worthy? I know you hate to be riddled with facts about baseball. So… if the Mets get Reyes & Beltran back on August 1st healthy you don’t think that’s a bigger move in the NL East than if say the Phillies get Erik Bedard?
Posted: 11:12 AM on July 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Don M
I kinda think of it the other way… the Marlins are a swing for the fences kinda team, with no bullpen
the Braves have pretty steady starting pitching.. Chipper Jones and Brian McCann both got off to slow starts.. and they have a solid bullpen..
we’ll see.. I think the Marlins are going to fall away as the year goes on.
When the Mets get healthy they’ll be solid again, but how much longer can they hang around .500 with their best players missing?
I wonder if the Nationals will win 60 games this year? .. what is the least amount of wins any team ever had?
Posted: 11:18 AM on July 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Amazinsux
The Muts coughed up two big leads the past two seasons WITH your litlle hot dog shortstop and your regular CF, so what’s to worry about? The Phils can stand pat and the Muts can have all their “starters” back. Who cares? Doesn’t matter. History says they lose again, only difference they won’t choke out a lead, because they will never smell first place this year. Face facts, don’t dream!
Posted: 11:21 AM on July 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Georgie
TIIIIMMMMMM!!!!! Man oh man we miss you around here. When I saw your name at the top of the post, I thought it was just another tease, but, as someone else said, a few sentences in I knew it was you. Welcome back, if only for just a day or two at a time.
Posted: 11:23 AM on July 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Don M
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_worst_MLB_season_records
damn.. the Phillies are on here a bunch of times in the 1930s and 1940s (Athletics too.. of the 23 teams on the list, Philadelphia teams are listed 9 times)
Recent teams include:
1962 Mets = 40 wins
2003 Tigers = 43 wins
Posted: 11:24 AM on July 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Jessep
Don: 62 Mets won 40 out of 160 games… I think the Tigers in 03 won 43 out of 162, which I believe it ehw rost ever in 162 game season…
Amazin… you’re too uneducated for me to respond to you anymore.
Posted: 11:29 AM on July 16, 2009