Phillies Survive Game One; Win 8-6
Posted by Amanda Orr, Fri, October 16, 2009 01:04 AM | Comments: 95
Posts
It’s never easy. The Phillies survived an 8-6 win over the Los Angeles Dodgers, taking a 1-0 advantage in the National League Championship Series. The pitching was shaky, but home runs by Carlos Ruiz and Raul Ibanez proved to be the difference.
There were hopes that Cole Hamels would return to form, especially against a team that he had so much success against. However, he is a completely different pitcher than the one who posted a sub-2 earned run average during the 2008 postseason. The Dodgers took a 1-0 lead on James Loney’s second inning home run. For awhile, it looked like that was all Clayton Kershaw would need. The 21-year old left-hander shut out the Phillies for four innings, but his 5.23 ERA against them this season showed that it wouldn’t last.
Carlos Ruiz showed why it’s ”Choochtober.” Ruiz is batting .348 with 10 RBI, five extra base hits, and eight walks in 18 postseason games. Ruiz’s three run home run gave the Phillies a 3-1 lead. In the same inning, Ryan Howard stroked a double down the right field line, similar to his hit during the final game of the division series. Howard’s 18 postseason runs batted in set a Phillies record. The Phillies took a 5-1 lead, but it didn’t take long for the Dodgers to strike back.
Hamels needed a “shut down inning.” He allowed a few base runners, but was close to escaping the jam. Andre Eithier grounded a dead double play ball, but Chase Utley airmailed the throw to first. The play was not fully Utley’s fault. Jimmy Rollins failed to get the ball out of his glove quickly. A run scored with Manny Ramirez due up. We all remember the troubles “Mannywood” gave the Phillies in last year’s NLCS. He had no trouble causing more problems. Manny smashed a deep fly ball to center field, stared at it for 15 minutes, then rounded the bases for a two-run home run. The lead was cut to one.
Hamels didn’t last much longer. He gave up four runs on eight hits in 5.1 innings. He struck out four and walked one. He now has a 6.97 ERA this postseason.
George Sherill hadn’t allowed a home run to a left-handed batter since June 14, 2008 against Adam LaRoche. The Dodgers acquired Sherill from the Baltimore Orioles for a reason: to get out lefties. Raul Ibanez had a different plan. Ibanez’s three-run shot gave the Phillies an 8-4 lead, and a little more breathing room.
Together, Chad Durbin and J.A Happ picked up Hamels’ pieces. Happ worked through a bases loaded jam without allowing a run to cross. Chan Ho Park, who just returned from a hamstring injury, was excellent in his seventh inning relief appearance. Park retired the three batters he faced and clocked 96 mph on the radar gun. On the other hand, Ryan Madson was atrocious in the eighth inning. He was lucky he did not allow more than two runs.
The ninth inning brought on Brad Lidge. Matt Kemp greeted him with a single. When the lead-off runner reaches base against Lidge, it’s usually a bad sign. However, Casey Blake hit a sharp ground ball to Utley. Utley made a fantastic play on a short hop, and was able to turn the double play. Ronnie Belliard flied out to end the game.
Friday, Pedro Martinez will start against former Phillie Vicente Padilla. A 2-0 series lead would be nice to return to Philadelphia with. Since the League Championship Series was extended to seven games, game one winners are 28-18. 29 doesn’t sound too bad.

















Posts: 0 phils_ftw
*correction – Raul’s THREE run shot, not two. Great post and recap though. :)
Posted: 01:12 AM on October 16, 2009
Posts: 0 marty
Raul Ibanez had a different plan. Ibanez’s two-run shot gave the Phillies an 8-5 lead, and a little more breathing room
that’s wrong…
it was a 3 run bomb…and it put the lead at 8-4
Posted: 01:15 AM on October 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Whizwithout
we all know what it was, no reason for 2 corrections…AND DO I LOVE THE PHILLIES!!! HITTING BOMBS IS OUR JOB. STILL GREAT TO SEE BRAD LIDGE ON TRACK, I THINK HE REALLY CLICKED IN THE PLAYOFFS…although i will still be nervous when hes on of course.
Posted: 01:33 AM on October 16, 2009
Posts: 0 mongolloyd
You can tell that Lidge has his confidence back when after the game he interrupts the lame TBS interviewer to make fun of his suit. TBS sucks at baseball and I will not watch George Lopez’s new show.
Posted: 01:42 AM on October 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Philly Texan
I love this team!
You look back at the game — 14 hits against, a costly error on a double-play ball, Manny goes deep, Madson gives up two runs — and you’re not sure how they won the game.
But win they do.
They’re just so mentally tough. That’s their biggest advantage.
Must-win tomorrow for the Dodgers. They can’t go to Philly down 0-2 and have to face Cliff Lee……
A win tomorrow and the series might be over. Lose, and we’re in for a long fight.
Let’s go for the jugular tomorrow!
Posted: 01:43 AM on October 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Morris Buttermaker
“Choochtober” is tattoo worthy.
Posted: 01:44 AM on October 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Philly Texan
I agree: TBS sucks.
Buck Martinez is generally pretty good.
But where did Ron Darling imagine that Ryan Madson has a good overhand curveball?
My favorite line, though, was when Chip Caray says: “If the Phillies hadn’t scored those three runs in the 8th, this would be a totally different game.”
Well, no sh*t.
Posted: 01:47 AM on October 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Mazinman
Thats why the TV feed in my house is very muted and the computer plays the Philly feed while I watch.
I was in the Dominican Republic this week on business and Phillies fever has gripped the island as many have adopted the Phillies because they took the chance on Pedro. I don’t think Pedro will disappoint.
Posted: 02:02 AM on October 16, 2009
Posts: 0 mikeB
Chase looked like he was out of it tonight and I do not say that just because he threw the ball in the dugout on the attempted double play. Acted like he was on pain medication. Wonder if the cold wet weather in Colorado caused his surgically repaired hip to ache?
Posted: 02:39 AM on October 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Mulvi
Wow! Just got back from the wonderful win of Game 1! The Dodger fans were their usual self, drunk, boorish, and profane. All the drinks thrown at me after Rauuul’s shot did miss, though one hit a girl in Dodger blue. But all that happened after we were interviewed by an LA Times writer asking visiting fans about Dodger crowds! Either way, AMAZING GAME! The only game I’ve been to that was better was MATT F***KIN’ STAIRS!!! Can’t wait for Pedro tomorrow!!!
I learned a lesson while leaving a ballpark after my team won 8-6, I was informed over and over that the “Phillies Suck!”, and that I suck as well. Ya know, it really makes me think…
Posted: 02:46 AM on October 16, 2009
Posts: 0 ActuallyChilled
Padilla.
Just the what the doctor ordered.
Too bad they didn’t want to start him in Game 3, for a ‘Flotilla’ reprise-mock at the Bank.
Posted: 02:54 AM on October 16, 2009
Posts: 0 ryan
this came down to a battle of the bullpens. and supposedly their bullpen was far superior to ours. but ours won. JA Happ and Chan ho Park deserve the Ashburn. they saved the game when it was in jeopardy.
Posted: 03:05 AM on October 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Craig
Raulllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll 100+ RBI’s for the season.
I called this back in April. Much to the derision of some on this board. Not naming any names Tim Malcom ;o)
Posted: 03:54 AM on October 16, 2009
Posts: 0 » Ruiz, Howard, Ibanez Lead Phillies Past Dodgers in NLCS Opener | Blogging-Baseball.com
[...] Philiies Nation’s Amanda Orr adds commentary and a few stats regarding the NLCS opener: Carlos Ruiz…. is batting .348 with 10 RBI, five extra base hits, and eight walks in 18 postseason games. [...]
Posted: 06:38 AM on October 16, 2009
Posts: 0 bfo_33
A displaced Phils fan in N Jersey. The media up here has decided that the Yankees will sweep (I do think they’ll win, but think it will go at least 6), and the Dodgers will win easily, since Torre coming back is a great story. I don’t understand it. Everyone says the Dodgers outfield is better (did their outfield start the all-star game?), their manager is better (Kershaw couldn’t throw a strike to start the 5th, let’s leave him in anyway – oops a 3 run homer, leave him in a bit more – walked the pitcher, well, let him pitch to the heart of the order to work himself out of it – yeah, I’ll take Charlie), somehow Casey Blake is a God (same offensively as Pedro, not nearly as good defensively), and of course, the Chooch factor – the real Mr October, can’t match up to the greatest catcher since Johnny Bench (3 wild pitches in one inning – granted, in the dirt, but 3?). I thought the Dodgers would take last night, and the series would go 6, but with the win, I can see 4 or 5. The games will be similar to last night, but the Phils won’t lose more than 1 (not even sure which one – I could see Pedro pitching a gem tonight).
Posted: 06:42 AM on October 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Papa Thompson
Mulvi, I made my first trip to Dodger Stadium in June and ran into similar accusations of sucking. “Defending world champions” is always a winning response in my book, but it’s probably best in this case to frame responses around our 1-0 series lead, and the fact we beat the Dodgers in five last year.
Posted: 07:08 AM on October 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Papa Thompson
Even though Madson got hit around a little bit, I think the bullpen was generally outstanding.
With this team right now, I can really only guess who might be coming in when Charlie goes to the mound or orders a pinch-hitter to bat in the pitcher’s spot. I didn’t really expect to see Durbin first out of the bullpen or Happ second. I was shocked to see Bastardo against Eithier in a tight game — and his giving up a double with two strikes really made things tough on Chan Ho.
Madson made a heck of a play coming off the mound and rifling that ball to second to keep the double play in order, even though it proved inconsequential. The best silver lining in Madson’s performance is that he stayed on the mound and worked out of his jam — and by sitting down Manny, who represented the go-ahead run.
I don’t know what to say about Lidge.
Utley looked OK to me. That ball he hit to the warning track in the 1st was DRILLED. He looked good rounding the bases on Howard’s double, worked deep into counts and started a lot of crucial groundouts. The throw was a fluke.
Posted: 07:32 AM on October 16, 2009
Posts: 0 PhillyPhaninNYC
I’m (unfortuantely) in NYC. Did the local media make as big of a deal out of Hamels “stare down” of Rollins/Utley after the throwing error as they did on the MLB network? Mitch Williams was fired up talking about it for a good five minutes, saying that it was “bush” and that Hamels mind is what separates him from last year’s success.
Posted: 07:48 AM on October 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Patrick
Did anyone else notice how overly ecstatic Chip Caray was when he called Manny’s homer? It was way over the top. Probably the worst I ever heard. Check it out.
Question: Did you guys hear what’s the quickest route to get from Colorado to Los Angeles?
Answer: Huston Street
Posted: 07:57 AM on October 16, 2009
Posts: 0 christopher
the entire bullpen that got in the game other than bastardo and madson come up huge. and i like charlie vote of confidence with bastardo there, although it didn’t pay off, i could see him coming up big in this series against lefties in a spot or two. he was one strike away and if he had stuck with his fastball he might have gotten it.
and speaking of charlie, how about putting the green light on ruiz and ibanez in situations where most managers would want them to wait until they had a strike on them to swing? FIRST PITCH bomb for ibanez even.
one hell of a slugfest to start the series, i can’t wait to see how pedro does today.
Posted: 08:12 AM on October 16, 2009
Posts: 0 JP
‘survive game one’? bad headline, a road win to start the series is a steal
Posted: 08:40 AM on October 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Brooks
Even watching MLB before the game, with the exception of Mitch they were singing the praises of the Dodgers left and right. Why is it that the defending world champions are lacking the respect they are due?
This has been so much fun to watch – unbelievable clutch hitting and frankly, much better than what we saw during the regular season and even in the post season last year. The Phils are outhit, yet are coming through with hits that are meaningful and put us ahead, time and time again…
Wow –
I still want a game 5 here at home.
Posted: 08:53 AM on October 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Brooks
I agree with the Philly_Texan, Chippy made me sick – you could barely hear what the dude was muttering when the Manram hit that hr to draw the Blues within 1. Certainly did not hear anywhere near that jubilation when Chooch hit his 3 run dinger or Rauuul hit his.
Unreal
Posted: 08:58 AM on October 16, 2009
Posts: 0 JD
Yeah I think Caray broke a speaker on my tv calling Manny’s homer…
Posted: 09:20 AM on October 16, 2009
Posts: 0 U Gotta Believe
Beat LA Beat LA….I have a good feeling about Pedro pitching tonight….a very very good feeling. This team is ridiculous…i can’t believe people still doubt them.
Posted: 09:21 AM on October 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Manny
What a game!! GO PHILLIES! 7 more wins!!!!!!!
Now, Utley nearly blew it with his throw… the inning would’ve been over and Hamels would’ve escaped the jam with a DP — like in many 2008 games. That play, in my opinion, is why Hamels didn’t pitch 7 innings or so… It completely rattled him, and even though he threw a good pitch to Manny, he immediately lost confidence in his pitches after Manny crushed that one. He was done.
Chan Ho was philthy, and Lidge got the save. The bullpen is looking better. Choochtober is the real deal, and RAUUUUUUUUUL hit a huge homer against the Dodgers bullpen guy I fear[ed] the most in this series… Awesome.
Posted: 09:32 AM on October 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Gart
Chumley was intense. It was a fluke, timing. F Manny. It’s all about him. This is a team. I can’t believe how MLB & TBS tout this LA thing! It makes me turn off the sound. They are stiffs in that booth. Darling has nothing. And how about that interview with Lidge? Carl (jackass) whatever his name is doesn’t even finish the interview and turns to Ibanez. TBS is horrible. As is MLB for letting this crap happen. Come on and step up.. I’d love to see this series end quick, with the Phil’s scoring tons of runs!!
Posted: 09:35 AM on October 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Geoff A.
Glad to hear that I am not alone in my views of TBS broadcasters essentially rooting against the Phillies. It was evident in the NLDS and much more so last night. That call on Manny’s homer was great as far as emotion, I like that in broadcasters. However, that should be the way you call them all the time and for anyone who hits a big one. Chooch’s was huge given that Kershaw was cruising to that point. Raul’s was even bigger given that the Dodgers pretty much got Sherrill to face Philly lefties in the playoffs oh and by the way hasn’t given up a homer to a lefty since June of 2008. Not to mention that both were 3 run shots. Did anyone else notice how every time the Dodgers had potential tying or winning runs at the plate they were fawning over the implications of a possible homer. I know I take it pretty personally when announcers lean heavily to one side but I am glad that others are as infuriated by it as I am. Let’s go Pedro, bring us home up 2-0! See you at the Bank for games 3, 4 and 5 if needed!
Posted: 09:43 AM on October 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Gart
TBS, a division of Turner Broadcasting System, Inc., is television’s top-rated comedy network. I thought that was a good one!
Posted: 09:45 AM on October 16, 2009
Posts: 0 hotstove
TBS- The Braves Suck station
Posted: 09:48 AM on October 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Geoff A.
We should see about starting a petition to allow local broadcasters to call the games , on TBS and Fox, in the local markets of the teams involved and let these bums they found do the rest of country (I am ok with Buck Martinez). TBS spent a ton of money to get the broadcasting rights this year and these are the best broadcasters they could muster up? Pathetic. Ok done complaining, it has just been festering since the Rockies series.
Posted: 09:48 AM on October 16, 2009
Posts: 0 TODDFROMFAIRMOUNT
Brad Lidge is our Closer. Choooooooooh!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Posted: 09:57 AM on October 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Ben
A couple notes. One, chooch should be named Sr. Octubre. Two, the announcers are terrible and their love for manny is laughable. First, during the replay of his hr the announcers said something along the lines of “Manny knows how to treat a homerun of this magnitude, he’s done so many before” as they showed him doing his post hit bat toss and then stair down the phils dugout. Then, they cannot say that he was suspended for steroids of PEDs, instead they say he was out for 50 games. Just irritating.
Posted: 10:02 AM on October 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Greg F.
The TBS announce team was simply awful. Caray was openly slobbering for a Dodger victory and genuflectuing before Manny. My fave: “you get the feeling the more pitches he see’s from Hamels the better he will be..” Hamels whiffs him on the next pitch. Or my other fave: “These are two evenly matched teams, and I think the Dodgers will prove it….” Or my line of the night: “it may seem sacreligious, but Kershaw reminds some of Sandy Koufax…” The guy is a pathetic Dodger homer. And yes, he barely sniffs at the Ruiz dinger, and comes out of his seat on Manny’s.
Posted: 10:06 AM on October 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Ben
Also, hamels did not pitch poorly. The double play would have gone a long way, he could have gone much deeper. Second, the ball Manny hit he was looking for. Hamels made a superb pitch, but the fact Manny was sitting change up b/c he can’t catch up to a 90+ mph fastball he went yard. I say the Phils pitchers pitch Manny with inside fastballs the rest of the series until he shows he can hit them.
Posted: 10:07 AM on October 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Don M
This probably already got mentioned.. but did anyone else want to punch Cole Hamels right in the face when they showed the replay after Utley threw that ball away
Hamels watches the play, and then sighs and throws his hands up in disbelief … I wanted to strangle him .. you can’t show your teammates up, d!ck !!!
especially when you are getting rocked.. if you had a no-hitter going, I wouldn’t care.. but you sucked last night and missed your spots too many times
Posted: 10:07 AM on October 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Kurt
Did anybody catch exactly what Lidge said about that interviewer’s ridiculous suit during the post-game interview? The clown didn’t even finish the interview with Lidge before turning his back mid-answer and tlaking with Ibanez. Lidge got in some sort of dig but the sound faded.
Posted: 10:07 AM on October 16, 2009
Posts: 0 charlie
Chen was nasty. His pitches were unhittable. He really looked good and hit 96 twice on the gun. When he gets his breaking pitch over with his heat, he can be so effective.
Madson was Madson, a run producing machine for the opposition.
Posted: 10:07 AM on October 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Don M
Hamels pitched GREAT the first 3 innings.. and then he started missing spots, and he started aiming instead of just throwing
that ball that Loney hit out was a pretty decent pitch.. a fastball on the inside half to a Lefty .. somehow Loney and Ramirez seem to feast on Cole Hamels
the above was just a rant.. Hamels pitched an OK game.. but I think the fact that he gets rattled, and shows his emotions when he’s on the field is part of the reason that people don’t love him.. and we’re all becomming bigger fans of Cliff Lee, Blanton, and Happ
Posted: 10:09 AM on October 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Gart
Craig Sager…..that is the clown who did the Lidge / Ibanez interview.
I couldn’t believe how he just butchered that interview. It really is horrible. Outside of that , has anyone noticed how bad the sound has been as well as the tiling of the games and delays!!!
Comcast should be doing this!! They have the cash!!
Posted: 10:10 AM on October 16, 2009
Posts: 0 charlie
don m You hit the nail on the head on Hamels. I am sick of him and his meltdowns. He is a sorry excuse for an ace. Gets a 4 run lead and gets rocked for 3 runs.
Posted: 10:10 AM on October 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Don M
Anyone know what happened to Orlando Hudson?? wasn’t he on the All-Star team this year … he looked COMPLETELY overmatched against Hamels when he pinch-hit in the 5th
Posted: 10:13 AM on October 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Ben
don m, completely agree with what you said about the missed dp. rollins couldn’t get it out and so utley rushed, they did the best they could. a double play is never a gimme, and even still that was only one run and we had a 3 run lead at that point. for hamels to be upset is ridiculous, he should have picked his teammates up instead of that.
Posted: 10:14 AM on October 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Gart
he got the win though….
team ball….
Posted: 10:14 AM on October 16, 2009
Posts: 0 Don M
I was being dramatic … he really didn’t get into any trouble until that 5th inning..
but I’m sick of his ON-FIELD drama … earlier this season he flipped the ball at Charlie that game when he sprained his ankle and had to leave the game (I defended him then as being a competitor and being mad at the situation)
..and I defended him last week saying that his regular season numbers weren’t as bad as people wanted to say they were.. and that regardless, those numbers get tossed out the window when the playoffs start
BUT.. he’s had two starts now, looked pretty sharp for MOST of his start yesterday, but then he started getting rattled.
He only walked one batter, but the Dodgers chased, and fouled-off countless HIGH fastballs with full-counts, etc.. (the umpire was all over the place last night, going more on situations, than any kind of established strike zone)
im just glad we won
Posted: 10:17 AM on October 16, 2009
Posts: 0 bob
I agree that was bush league by Hamels. Surprising because this team is known for their composure. I’ll chalk it up to a bad moment.
WOW! What a game…
Chan Ho: love ya man, just awesome.
RAUUUUUUUUUUULLLLLL
I give Madson credit for battling. He looked bad, but to get out of that inning only allowing 2 runs really saved the game. He will rebound.
Brad Lidge, credit to you. U never quit, never gave in. He is starting to resemble the rock at the back of the pen in 2008.
Charlie was outstanding in getting those matchups. It got dicey, but I understood the moves he had to make.
Magic number: 7. Let’s get em one game at a time. LETS GO PEDRO!!!
Posted: 10:18 AM on October 16, 2009
Posts: 0 bob
Whoops, how did I forget CHHHHHHOOOOOOOOCCCCCCCHHHHH! And Mr. Clutch, Ryan Howard!
Posted: 10:19 AM on October 16, 2009
Posts: 0 beta sigma shag
IMO the biggest difference between these two teams, is class.
What did Chooch and Raul do after they hit their homers, both just ran around the bases. Especially Raul he knew it was gone, and just went about his business and rounded the bases.
And then you have Manny Steriod Boy Ramirze pose at the plate and stare into the Phillies dug out. Hey Manny you team is still losing. I do not mind show boating when it is a Homer that gives you the lead or is a bomb, not that it was a sure home run, but it was not a upper deck shot. Round the bases and have a little class, when the game was on the line in the later innings with runners in scoring position what did you do, oh yea 0-2.
Ryan Howard did not have a home run, but to extend the lead he got his hit.
I would almost vote for Chopper for Ashburn, that was a key point in the game and he dominated.
And what can you say about Chooch, the man is clutch
On the Cole front, he did let that error frustrate him, and why he did not fire fastballs at Manny I just do not know, the guy since he has been off the Juice can not hit the inside fastball, really 3 straight changeups? Other than that I thought he pitched well, and I would have no problem with him pitching game 5 in phila. if needed. It would be nice to see a sweep since I have tickets to games 3 and 4.
Pedro can bring us one step closer this afternoon and really put the dodgers in a big hole 2-0
Posted: 10:20 AM on October 16, 2009
Posts: 0 joedad
Mulvi, classless fans there in Los Mexico, I mean Los Angeles.
I fell asleep on the couch when Sherrill came into the game. I’ve been working like a dog non-stop for weeks and was comfortable enough in the Phils chances that i could doze off for an inning or 2. I woke up when I heard the crack of the bat on Ibanez’ home run and laughed when they had the camera in the Phils dugout and here on of the Phils yelling “Sherrill, Sherrill” in a high pitched voice. Funny stuff. Needless to say, i couldn’t sleep after that. It was a somewhat dramatic game although I never doubted the Phils would pull it off.
Manuel is the manager of the playoffs so far.
Posted: 10:22 AM on October 16, 2009
Posts: 0 TrappedInNYC
Should have left Chan Ho in for the 8th…but maybe Charlie didn’t want to burn him so he could use him tonight…the look in Park’s eyes was intense…if you have ever served or worked with Koreans you know they are total warriors. I live in KoreaTown here and you should see how people watch Phillies games just to see Chan Ho…they are so proud of him. And by the way…the Koufax remark is probably the dumbest thing I have ever heard.
Posted: 10:24 AM on October 16, 2009