PN Interview: Curt Simmons

Posted by Ian Riccaboni, Wed, March 12, 2014 08:00 AM | Comments: 6
Features, History, Phillies Nation Top 100 - 2014, PN Interview

Yesterday, I had the privilege of meeting with legendary Phillies’ left-handed pitcher Curt Simmons. I met with Simmons, a native of Egypt, PA, at his home and discussed, at length, the 1950 Whiz Kids, his roots in the Lehigh Valley, and the Phillies Nation Top 100 countdown.

The full-length interview will air on an upcoming television program by FireRock Productions, a multiple-time Emmy and ADDY-winning production company in the Lehigh Valley. Some of the excerpts below, and much more, will appear in a project Pat Gallen and I are working on.

We do not want to give the whole interview away, as we shot a ton of footage with Mr. Simmons, but I thought it would be neat to share some of Simmons’ thoughts on some of his teammates he played with that also made the Phillies Nation Top 100. For those keeping track at home, Simmons ranked #17 on our countdown.

You will want to stay tuned for the full interview where Simmons and I talk about what it was like to play for Babe Ruth against a team managed by Ty Cobb, having to leave the Phillies in September 1950, and what it was like to be on the Cardinals in 1964, chasing down the Phillies just a few years after the Phillies cut him loose.

On the Whiz Kids

“In 1950, everybody got together and most of the guys had good years, ya know? That’s what got us past the Dodgers. They were the cream of the crop, in those days. We got rolling and a lot of guys had good years. That’s what it takes – to get ‘em all going. You can’t have two guys with good years and the rest of the guys slushing along. (A pennant-winning team) doesn’t work like that.”

On Granny Hamner (Ranked #64 on the PN Top 100)

“A real good hitter. A clutch hitter. Good fielder with a good arm. A real rough, tough guy. He was one of our stars in those days.”

On the best player that didn’t make the Top 100, according to Simmons, Jim Konstanty

“In those days, Jim was our so-called closer but in those days, he would pitch, three innings, four innings, ya know, whatever it took. And he won 15 games, and a few of them (laughter) were probably my games when we rallied late in the games. He had a great year, one of the top players for sure.”

On Robin Roberts (Ranked #3)

“Robbie and I were neighbors in Abington Township at the time. In ’50, he blossomed to be the ace and I started coming on finally, knocking down my base on balls and stuff and relaxing and pitching, having a great year. He was a real bulldog, he was a fighter.”

On Richie Ashburn (Ranked #6)

“(Ashburn) could run ‘em down. He was an outstanding center fielder.”

On Del Ennis (Ranked #23)

“You could be assured Ennis would drive in 100 runs every year. He was a tough guy – the one time, he comes back to the dugout and says, ‘(The pitcher) hit me with that pitch.’ The umpire didn’t see it, of course, but (Ennis) didn’t say anything, he wanted to hit! He was a good player.”

On Andy Seminick (Ranked #50)

“Andy Seminick was a tough older guy (note: Seminick was 29 for most of the 1950 season, making him at least four years older than the Whiz Kids’ five most used starting pitchers and among their oldest regular players). You know, they talk now about blocking the plate, he would block the plate even before the ball got there and nail the guy at home. He had a great year in 1950, as well. There was no tension between him and Stan Lopata about playing time at catcher.”

On Stan Lopata (Ranked #49)

“Stan was not a rookie but came up in 1948 and Seminick was the head guy but then broke his ankle. (Lopata) had a lot of home runs and developed into a great player. I think he led the league in triples (among catchers) a few times. Not a lot of catchers could run but he could! He immitated Musial at the plate later on; Musial did it from the left side and Stan did it from the right side. (Lopata) started crouching and he really started to hit the ball, his hitting really improved.”

On facing Dick Allen as a Cardinal (Ranked #10)

“I’d see (Allen) at these old-timer events and (Allen) would say ‘I could never hit you!’ and I would say ‘Don’t give me that stuff!’ I can’t remember but apparently I got him out quite a bit. He was a strong guy, he was a great hitter for sure.”

(Note: Allen hit .378/.478/.568 for his career against Simmons. Allen must be very modest.)

Favorite Memories as a Hitter

“I only had one home run. It was an inside-the-park home run; it was an outstanding thing. I used to be able to run, believe it or not! I was a skinny guy, 180, 190 lbs, 180 lbs in those days. Bobby Del Greco was 18 and playing for Pittsburgh. Pittsburgh in those years had a lot of rookies playing. I hit a line drive to center field and he came in on the ball, so I must have hit it pretty good. I circled the bases standing up!”


“Yes, I did allow only one run in Game 3 of the 1964 World Series and I had the RBI, too! When I left the game it was 1-1. They replaced me in the 9th inning for a pinch hitter, which was the right move. I heard the crowd at Yankee Stadium get loud, turned into a roar as I was in the hallway headed to the locker room. I thought maybe Barney Schultz left the ball up and gave up a single. The crowd got louder and I thought it was a double. I guess his knuckleball didn’t knuckle and Mickey Mantle apparently hit a tremendous home run.”

On the best pitcher he saw throw or faced as a hitter

“There were a lot of good pitchers in those days. Warren Spahn, he was left-handed, he was outstanding. Then, of course, there was Roberts. Then when I went to St. Louis, Bob Gibson and of course Steve Carlton was just beginning when I was leaving there and he turned out to be an outstanding pitcher, too. So those guys, I saw their action pretty good, they were great pitchers.”

Avatar of Ian Riccaboni

About Ian Riccaboni

Ian Riccaboni has written 842 articles on Phillies Nation.

Ian's athletic achievements include getting stuffed by NBA center Aaron Gray in high school and hitting .179 over four years for NYU against D-III, NAIA, JuCo, and NCBA schools. Ian hopes his athletic successes will help him achieve his dream of becoming the underground Bob Uecker.

  • Posts: 191 photoFred

    Avatar of photoFred

    Looking forward to hearing why the Phillies didn’t try to get him into the world series. Is their worry about him being rusty and possibly hurting his arm really the whole story? That may be true but it just doesn’t sound very smart. You’re in the world series against the Yankees; you need all your weapons. There’s got to be more to it.

    You did ask him about that, Ian, right?

    • Posts: 452 Ian Riccaboni

      Avatar of Ian Riccaboni


      I did ask him that. He said it came down to logistics. He tells us a really cool story about Robin Roberts and the guys calling him to tell him that they’ve won the pennant. He goes a little more in depth on camera. Unfortunately, the video footage is with FireRock so I cannot transcribe it for you at this time.

      • Posts: 191 photoFred

        Avatar of photoFred

        Okay Ian, thanks. I assume you’ll give us a heads up when the interview lands on the schedule. (My Tivo is waiting:-)

  • Posts: 0 Bart Shart

    Nice tribute to a great Phillie. I wonder what he thinks of our current players and how much they earn for accomplishing little? How many would have made it back in the Golden Era of baseball?

  • Posts: 0 bacardipr

    This is good stuff Ian. I think some of these older often forgotten players of the past should be bought into the limelight more often.

  • Posts: 17 whizkidfanatic

    Avatar of whizkidfanatic

    Great idea! Curt is a class act and what stuff he had in those days! Frank Baumholtz said the best thing about being traded to the Phillies was knowing he wouldn’t have to face Curt Simmons. A lot of hitters echoed that. Be fun to hear his take on the Whizkids in 1950.

    Konstanty in ’50 was incredible. As Curt pointed out, he was really a long and short man. He pitched nine innings one time in an extra inning game and won it. At one point he went something like 38 or 39 innings in a row without giving up a run.

Leave a Comment

>> Create a new Phillies Nation account.
>> Already registered with Phillies Nation? Log in here.
>> Comment without logging in:

Please ensure your comments comply with our Comment Policy.