Categories: 2024 Postgame Recaps

Walker struggles, Marsh leaves with injury and Phillies lose in extras

Taijuan Walker struggled Sunday. (Grace Del Pizzo/Phillies Nation)

The Philadelphia Phillies have the NL’s best record, but Sunday evening’s extra-inning loss to the St. Louis Cardinals offered a glimpse into where the team may have deficiencies — starter No. 5, keeping hamstrings healthy and finding a way to plate the ghost runner in extra innings.

On the night, Taijuan Walker gave up five hits, four earned runs, walked three and allowed two home runs. He did strike out five, and lasted five innings. But the 31-year-old allowed six balls hit at 100 mph or harder, and saw his ERA on the season spike to 5.73.

A night after Spencer Turnbull pitched three hitless innings in relief of Ranger Suárez — who departed after just two innings with a left hand contusion — there were scattered “We want Turnbull!” chants in the crowd of more than 41,000 fans at Citizens Bank Park. While the Phillies avoided disaster with Suárez, they don’t yet know if he’ll make his next scheduled start in London next Saturday. If he doesn’t, Turnbull will replace him in the rotation for as long as is needed.

But even if Walker is only in the second season of a four-year/$72 million deal, you have to wonder how many more outings he has like Sunday before the Phillies consider pulling the plug, whatever that would look like. It’s one thing to have a 4.73 ERA. It’s another to be at 5.73, and to continuously put the Phillies in a hole in his starts.

Perhaps even more noteworthy is that left fielder Brandon Marsh left the game in the bottom of the eighth inning after coming up lame running around second base. He departed the game with what the Phillies called a right hamstring strain, with further evaluation set to take place. We’ll have more on that postgame.

Ultimately, the Cardinals were able to push a run across in extra innings, while the Phillies stranded the ghost runner in the form of Bryce Harper at third base. The Phillies are now 4-6 in extra innings this season.

Highlights

Nolan Gorman started the scoring in the top of the first inning, with a two-run home run off of Walker that snuck just inside the right-field foul pole:

After a Masyn Winn error negated what should have been a double play grounded into by Nick Castellanos in the bottom of the second inning, Garrett Stubbs doubled into right-center field, scoring Brandon Marsh:

Johan Rojas then brought Castellanos home with an RBI groundout, temporarily tying the game.

The 2-2 tie was short-lived, however, as Alec Burleson clubbed a two-run shot off of the facing of the second deck in right field to allow the Cardinals to retake the lead:

Stubbs and Rojas each reached on bunts to open the bottom of the fifth, with Lance Lynn and Iván Herrera both making errors that allowed them to reach base. Kyle Schwarber followed with a single to load the bases, before Bryson Stott unloaded them with a game-tying, two-run single into left field: